The Hidden Challenges of Advisor Migration and Finding the Right Fit
In this episode of Bird's Eye View, Steve Phillips focuses on advisor migration and the parallels between movement in nature and change within the financial services industry. Drawing from his decades of experience as both a birder and advisor coach, Steve explores why advisors choose to move firms, platforms, or business models in pursuit of growth, improved client experiences, stronger team support, and better long-term outcomes. Using the seasonal migration of birds as a powerful metaphor, he examines the importance of intentional decision-making, strategic planning, and finding the right fit rather than making repeated changes that fail to deliver desired results. This episode offers advisors valuable perspective on evaluating opportunities, building stability, and focusing on what matters most for clients, teams, and long-term success.
SUMMARY
Migration is one of nature's most fascinating phenomena. Every year, millions of birds embark on remarkable journeys, traveling thousands of miles between breeding grounds and winter habitats. While the concept of migration is typically associated with wildlife, Steve Phillips believes the idea has a surprising connection to a trend that has become increasingly common within the financial services industry. In this episode of Bird's Eye View, Steve introduces a new series focused on advisor migration, exploring why financial advisors move, what motivates those decisions, and how advisors can think more intentionally about major business transitions.
As someone who has spent more than 35 years both birding and coaching financial advisors, Steve has developed a unique perspective on the similarities between these two worlds. At first glance, bird migration and advisor transitions may seem entirely unrelated. One is driven by nature and survival, while the other involves professional decisions, business growth, and personal goals. Yet both involve movement, change, and the pursuit of better outcomes.
The episode begins with a discussion about bird migration, one of the most recognizable behaviors in the natural world. Even people with little interest in birding understand the basic concept. As seasons change, many species travel from northern regions to warmer southern climates and then return again when conditions improve. During the fall, birds that spent the summer breeding and raising their young begin making their way south toward winter habitats in Central and South America.
Steve explains that migration is not a random event. Birds do not wake up one morning and decide it is time to leave. Their movements are driven by powerful biological instincts connected to seasonal changes. Interestingly, migration is influenced less by temperature than many people realize. Instead, changing daylight patterns provide signals that trigger migratory behavior. As the position of the sun shifts and days become shorter, birds instinctively recognize that it is time to begin their journey.
The migration process is already underway as Steve records the episode. Living in Kansas City places him along important migratory pathways, allowing him to observe species that only appear briefly during their seasonal travels. Some birds stop for a few days to rest, feed, and regain energy before continuing their journeys south. These temporary visitors create exciting opportunities for birders while illustrating the purpose and planning that characterize successful migration.
Unlike birds, advisors do not move because of instinct. Human decisions are far more complex, involving personal goals, business needs, financial considerations, and emotional factors. Yet Steve notes that advisor migration has become one of the defining trends of the financial services industry over the past decade, particularly within the last five years.
Advisors change firms, platforms, broker-dealers, custodians, and business models for countless reasons. Some seek greater independence. Others want access to better technology, stronger marketing support, enhanced client experiences, or opportunities to grow their teams. Many are motivated by a desire to improve efficiency, increase profitability, or create a more sustainable business model.
Financial incentives often play a role as well. While Steve acknowledges that compensation opportunities can be attractive, he emphasizes that money alone is rarely the complete story. Most advisors are ultimately looking for predictable progress and an environment that supports their long-term goals.
What makes advisor migration particularly interesting, however, is that not every transition produces the desired results. Advisors often invest significant time, energy, and resources into making a move, only to discover that the reality does not match their expectations. In some cases, the challenges they hoped to solve remain unresolved. In others, new challenges emerge that were not fully anticipated.
As a result, some advisors find themselves moving again. What begins as a search for improvement can become a cycle of repeated migrations, with advisors continually pursuing solutions that remain just out of reach.
Steve encourages advisors to pause and think critically about this pattern. If an advisor repeatedly feels the need to change environments, there may be deeper questions worth exploring. Perhaps expectations and outcomes are not properly aligned. Maybe critical aspects of culture, support, leadership, or long-term fit have not been fully evaluated. While no organization is perfect, the goal should be finding a platform that supports sustainable growth rather than creating a series of short-term transitions.
The birding analogy becomes even more interesting when Steve points out that not all birds migrate. While some species undertake extraordinary journeys every year, many others remain in the same region throughout the seasons.
In Kansas City, species such as chickadees, titmice, bluebirds, cardinals, and robins often stay year-round despite freezing temperatures, snow, and challenging winter conditions. These birds do not escape difficult seasons by heading south. Instead, they adapt. They find food sources, establish shelter, and learn how to thrive in their environment.
For Steve, this presents an important lesson. Migration is not always the answer. Sometimes success comes from adapting to challenges rather than leaving them behind. The birds that remain through winter are not necessarily stronger than migrating species, but they have developed strategies that allow them to flourish where they already are.
This perspective offers valuable insight for advisors evaluating whether a move is truly necessary. Sometimes a new platform or organization can create tremendous opportunities. In other situations, however, the better solution may be improving processes, investing in team development, strengthening client relationships, or making adjustments within the current business environment.
The key is intentionality.
Throughout the episode, Steve repeatedly returns to the importance of understanding desired outcomes before making major decisions. Advisors should clearly define what success looks like before pursuing a migration. Are they seeking growth? Better support? Enhanced marketing resources? Improved client service? Greater operational efficiency? A stronger cultural fit?
Without clarity around objectives, it becomes difficult to determine whether a move is actually successful. Advisors who understand their goals can more effectively evaluate opportunities and avoid making decisions based solely on short-term frustrations or external pressures.
The concept of roots also emerges as an important theme. While migration can be necessary and beneficial, stability has value as well. Building a successful advisory practice often requires long-term commitment, deep relationships, and consistency. Clients value continuity, team members benefit from stability, and business growth frequently accelerates when leaders are focused on execution rather than constant transition.
Steve suggests that the ideal migration may be the one that only needs to happen once. Finding the right environment, putting down roots, and building toward a long-term vision can create a stronger foundation than repeatedly searching for the next opportunity.
As the episode draws to a close, Steve returns to several recurring themes that define Bird's Eye View. He encourages listeners to continue building their life lists, not only in birding but also in business and personal life. A life list can include birds observed, clients served, relationships built, milestones achieved, and memories created. Each represents part of a larger story that reflects what truly matters over time.
He also reminds listeners to step back occasionally and appreciate the view. Amid busy schedules, business demands, and professional ambitions, taking time to observe progress and appreciate meaningful moments remains important. Finally, he encourages advisors to stay intentional about what matters most, using that principle as a guide for both personal and professional decisions.
The first installment of this migration series sets the stage for deeper discussions about advisor movement, strategic change, and long-term business success. By comparing the instinctive journeys of birds with the calculated decisions advisors face throughout their careers, Steve offers a thoughtful reminder that lasting success depends not simply on movement, but on moving with purpose.
--
Author Info
Steve Phillips is the Chief Practice Management and Development Officer, joining USA Financial in 2019. He leads the coaching and...
Related Posts
Stop Treating Your Best Services Like Extras
Many advisors deliver exceptional value-added services, but few deliver them intentionally. In this episode of The Rare Advisor, Aaron Grady explores why some firms create memorable client experiences while others leave valuable services hidden in the background. Learn how to transform value-added services from occasional perks into a core pillar of your value proposition, create repeatable delivery processes, reinforce their value over time, and help clients fully understand the breadth of support your firm provides. If you've ever wondered why clients don't always recognize everything you do for them, this episode is for you.
How Financial Advisors Can Create Momentum During Quiet Seasons
In this episode of Bird's Eye View, Steve Phillips explores the surprising similarities between birding and financial advisor coaching, focusing on a challenge many advisors face each summer: slowing business activity. While vacations, family schedules, and seasonal distractions can make summer feel unproductive, Steve explains why this can actually be one of the most valuable times to strengthen client relationships. By focusing on meaningful conversations about family, vacations, children, and life transitions, advisors can deepen trust and better understand the people they serve.
Why Financial Advisors Lose Prospects Before the First Meeting
Most financial advisors think the prospect journey begins when someone schedules a meeting. In reality, it starts much earlier. In this episode of the Financial Advisor Marketing Playbook, Mark Mersman breaks down the modern prospect journey and explains how today's prospects research advisors before ever picking up the phone. From Google searches and websites to reviews, videos, social proof, and follow-up systems, you'll learn how to identify hidden trust gaps and improve the client experience before the first appointment ever takes place.
Stop Treating Your Best Services Like Extras
Many advisors deliver exceptional value-added services, but few deliver them intentionally. In this episode of The Rare Advisor, Aaron Grady explores why some firms create memorable client experiences while others leave valuable services hidden in the background. Learn how to transform value-added services from occasional perks into a core pillar of your value proposition, create repeatable delivery processes, reinforce their value over time, and help clients fully understand the breadth of support your firm provides. If you've ever wondered why clients don't always recognize everything you do for them, this episode is for you.
How Financial Advisors Can Create Momentum During Quiet Seasons
In this episode of Bird's Eye View, Steve Phillips explores the surprising similarities between birding and financial advisor coaching, focusing on a challenge many advisors face each summer: slowing business activity. While vacations, family schedules, and seasonal distractions can make summer feel unproductive, Steve explains why this can actually be one of the most valuable times to strengthen client relationships. By focusing on meaningful conversations about family, vacations, children, and life transitions, advisors can deepen trust and better understand the people they serve.
Why Financial Advisors Lose Prospects Before the First Meeting
Most financial advisors think the prospect journey begins when someone schedules a meeting. In reality, it starts much earlier. In this episode of the Financial Advisor Marketing Playbook, Mark Mersman breaks down the modern prospect journey and explains how today's prospects research advisors before ever picking up the phone. From Google searches and websites to reviews, videos, social proof, and follow-up systems, you'll learn how to identify hidden trust gaps and improve the client experience before the first appointment ever takes place.
